Interactive webcast player

Dún Laoghaire CHEPP Area Committee meeting
Monday, 5th October 2026 at 4:50pm

 
Share this agenda point
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Marie Baker
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Cllr Marie Baker
  4. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  5. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  6. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  7. Cllr Marie Baker
  8. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  9. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  10. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  11. Cllr Marie Baker
  12. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  13. Cllr Marie Baker
  14. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  15. Cllr Marie Baker
  16. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  17. Cllr Marie Baker
  18. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  19. Cllr Marie Baker
  20. Cllr John Kennedy
  21. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  22. Cllr Marie Baker
  23. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  24. Cllr Marie Baker
  25. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  26. Cllr Marie Baker
  27. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  28. Cllr Marie Baker
  29. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  30. Cllr Marie Baker
  31. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  32. Cllr Marie Baker
  33. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  34. Cllr Marie Baker
  35. Cllr Justin Moylan
  36. Cllr Marie Baker
  37. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  38. Cllr Marie Baker
  39. Cllr Dave O'Keeffe
  40. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  41. Cllr Carrie Smyth
  42. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  43. Cllr Marie Baker
  44. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  45. Cllr Marie Baker
  46. Cllr Carrie Smyth
  47. Cllr Marie Baker
  48. Cllr Thomas Joseph
  49. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
Share this agenda point
  1. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  4. Cllr Marie Baker
  5. Cllr Jim Gildea
  6. Cllr Marie Baker
  7. Ms. Deirdre Cronin
  8. Cllr Marie Baker
  9. Cllr Jim Gildea
  10. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Carrie Smyth
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Marie Baker
  2. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  3. Cllr Marie Baker
  4. Cllr Jim Gildea
  5. Cllr Marie Baker
  6. Ms. Karen Cahill
  7. Cllr Marie Baker
  8. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  9. Cllr Marie Baker
  10. Ms. Karen Cahill
  11. Cllr Marie Baker
  12. Cllr Carrie Smyth
  13. Cllr Marie Baker
  14. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Mr James Ryan
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  4. Cllr Marie Baker
  5. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  6. Cllr Marie Baker
  7. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  8. Cllr Marie Baker
  9. Cllr Hugh Lewis
  10. Cllr Tom Kivlehan
  11. Cllr Justin Moylan
  12. Cllr Jim Gildea
  13. Cllr Marie Baker
  14. Cllr Tom Kivlehan
  15. Mr James Ryan
  16. Cllr Marie Baker
  17. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  18. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Michael Clark
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Mr James Ryan
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Michael Clark
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Mr James Ryan
  4. Cllr Marie Baker
  5. Cllr Michael Clark
  6. Cllr Marie Baker
  7. Cllr Jacqueline Burke
  8. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Jim Gildea
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Cllr Jim Gildea
  4. Cllr Marie Baker
  5. Cllr Carrie Smyth
  6. Cllr Marie Baker
  7. Cllr Jacqueline Burke
  8. Cllr Marie Baker
  9. Mr James Ryan
  10. Cllr Marie Baker
  11. Cllr Jim Gildea
  12. Cllr Marie Baker
  13. Mr James Ryan
  14. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Thomas Joseph
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Cllr Justin Moylan
  4. Cllr Marie Baker
  5. Cllr Jacqueline Burke
  6. Cllr Marie Baker
  7. Cllr Mary Fayne
  8. Mr James Ryan
  9. Cllr Marie Baker
  10. Mr James Ryan
  11. Cllr Marie Baker
  12. Cllr Melisa Halpin
  13. Cllr Marie Baker
  14. Cllr Thomas Joseph
  15. Cllr Marie Baker
  16. Mr James Ryan
  17. Cllr Marie Baker
  18. Mr James Ryan
  19. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Michael Clark
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Cllr Maurice Dockrell
  4. Mr James Ryan
  5. Cllr Marie Baker
  6. Cllr Michael Clark
  7. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Carrie Smyth
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Marie Baker
Share this agenda point
  1. Ms. Karen Cahill
  2. Cllr Marie Baker
  3. Webcast Finished

Part 1 - Confirmation and adoption of minutes of the Dún Laoghaire Area Committee meeting CHEPP held on 7th September

Cllr Marie Baker - 0:01:10
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:01:21
Good evening, members. We are going to get started. Before we
begin, let me read the health and safety statement, et cetera.
I would like to draw your attention to the emergency exits,
both doors on the right -hand side of the room. In the unlikely
event of the alarm sounding, please exit in a calm and orderly
fashion and follow the instructions of the porters and staff
on duty.
Webcasting statement at this meeting may be filmed for live
or subsequent broadcast via the Council's website. Therefore,
by attending the meeting and by entering the remote teams
meeting area conference room, you are consenting to being
filmed and to the possible use of those images and sound
recording through webcasting.
Data protection. Please note the Council's subject of GDPR
and data protection legislation. As this meeting may be filmed
for live or subsequent broadcasts via the Council's website, no
data which identifies or could identify a private citizen should
be disclosed during the meeting.
Loss of Wi -Fi connection. Please inform the Chair if you
lose connection or if you wish to leave the meeting before the
Standing orders are still in place and speaking times and items
remain the same.
The use of AI software is not permitted by members
attending on teams.
AI note takers should be disabled and not used during the
meeting.
This meeting, just for members, information will
conclude at 5 .55pm due to the industrial action.
So we will go to a roll call, please.
Who is doing the roll call?
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:03:02
I'm here. Sorry. Councillor Baker. I'm still here. Councillor Burke.
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:03:10
Here. Councillor.
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:03:20
Councillor Dan Carson. Apologies.
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:03:24
Councillor Michael Clark. Anseo.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:03:31
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:03:32
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:03:39
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:03:42
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:03:47
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:03:52
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:03:55
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:03:58
Councillor Maurice Dockrell. Here. Councillor Conor Dowling. Anseo. Councillor JP Durkan. Anseo. Councillor Martha Fanning
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:02
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:04
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:06
Councillor Mary Fayne. Councillor Jim Gildea. Anseo
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:11
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:14
Cllr John Kennedy - 0:04:17
Councillor Lorraine Hall. Here.
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:19
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:21
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:04:25
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:27
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:30
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:31
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:34
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:35
here. Councillor Melissa Halpin. Here. Councillor Thomas Joseph. Councillor Tom Kivlehan. Here.
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:39
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:41
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:45
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:47
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:50
here. Councillor Hugh Lewis. Here. Councillor Frank McNamara. Here. Councillor Justin Moylan.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:53
Cllr Justin Moylan - 0:04:55
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:56
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:04:57
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:04:59
Cllr Dave O'Keeffe - 0:05:02
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:05:04
Anseo. Councillor Dave O 'Keefe. Here. Councillor Carrie Smyth. Here. Councillor Lauren Tuite
Cllr Carrie Smyth - 0:05:07
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:05:08
Anseo.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:05:10
19 present, Cathaoirleach.
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:05:13
Thank you.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:05:15
So can I have item one is the confirmation of minutes from the last meeting.
Opposer?
Carrie Smyth.
Thank you.
Be brief please.
Cllr Carrie Smyth - 0:05:25
I will be very brief.
Just regarding agenda item 11 on the 6th of May.
Tell us what it is about please.
In the report it was to do pump tracks and in the report it said that a headed item would
be coming on playgrounds and teen spaces to the September or October meeting and they
have not been on either of those meetings and it was agreed that we would get an update
on the playgrounds and all every couple of months.
Maybe it could be on the November meeting.
Thanks.
Would anyone like to propose the minutes?
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:06:00
Cllr Thomas Joseph - 0:06:06
I passed a motion last meeting. It mentioned DLC126 and
I am expecting a report.
And it is about?
About the Hudson Park.
There is no report. I don't know when we can see the report.
We will look into that as well.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:06:25
Do I have any proposers for the minutes?
Proposed Councillor Kivlehan. Thank you Councillor Kivlehan.
And seconded by Carrie Smyth.
Moving on to questions, proposer, for one to 13.
Councillor Clark and seconded by Councillor Gildea.

Part 2 - Questions

Moving swiftly along then to item 3.
I think I am passing over to you, Deirdre, for this. Just a moment please.

3. Management and Maintenance of Shanganagh Castle Estate – Cushman/Wakefield

Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:06:55
Members, This item is being deferred.
It was in relation to the request for the management company, Cushman and Wakefield,
as well as the Land Development Agency to attend a future meeting of – we actually
stated in the minutes that it will be to attend a future meeting and send a letter to them
to ask to come to a future meeting of the Dun Laoghaire -Rathdown CHEP meeting.
They were going to come to a meeting today, but this item is being deferred and will be
reentered on the next area committee meeting in November.
While they were able to be invited to attend in response to
the request from the elected members, it has been decided that
postponing the item would provide greater clarity for all
concerned and allow for more structured discussion at the next
meeting, if that is okay with the members.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:07:47
Councillor Halpin, I know this was on foot of your motion as
far as I remember.
I think it was probably Dave's Wasn't it.
Your joint motion.
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:07:50
Surely we decide to defer. Why wasn't that written in this report? It would be useful
to know rather than have a blank report.
I would agree with you entirely.
Just for future reference. If we are going to get a better report next month, great.
But that should have been written in that rather than us just hearing it now. Thanks for passing it.
It will be great to hear it next month but in the future can we have as much info as
possible in advance?
Thank you.
Thank you.
Councillor Gildea, not long please.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:08:23
Cllr Jim Gildea - 0:08:26
Do we have any reason for the postponement?
Because it shouldn't happen.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:08:32
Ms. Deirdre Cronin - 0:08:34
Just to let you know, that is due to the industrial relations activity at the moment that we are
unable to provide a representative from the executive to be here to respond to queries.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:08:51
Cllr Jim Gildea - 0:08:52
So that's fine, but if we just know that it's not Wakefield and Co that are –
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:08:58
No, in fairness to Cushman and Wakefield, they were willing to come, but for other reasons
it has to be deferred.
Agreed?
We'll see it on the agenda next month.
Right.
Minister of the department, other correspondence, nothing to be looked at there.

4. Ministerial/Departmental/Other Correspondence

Councillor Smyth, sorry that should be noted, your motion, seconded by Councillor Gildea.
Cllr Carrie Smyth - 0:09:22
I am just trying to open up the file and it is not responding.

5. Councillor C. Smyth

Do you have it there?
Do you have a hard copy?
Very good.
Thank you for being so helpful.
I did have a look at it when we received the documentation at the time, but for some reason
it's not opening at the moment.
I'd like to thank, I think it's Aoife that, sorry, Karen who compiled the report.
It's very good and unfortunately includes a lot of properties.
From what I can see, just a couple of questions.
A number of units up in the Grange in Stillorgan are undergoing fire safety works and have
been vacant it looks like for the last two and a half years.
I just scanning through quite quickly I think a huge number are the Coral, the Abalone and
other in the Grange up in Stillorgan are undergoing fire safety works and are not available and
it's April since they were vacated.
So just wondering what's the delay like?
It's two and a half years.
The other issue that I noticed that kind of jumped out at me was the number of units that
are in the allocation process.
And yet from memory these would have been advertised on CBL a number of weeks ago because
it's nearly two months since units have been on CBL.
So what does that mean?
If you were to take off all those in the allocation process and those that are undergoing the
fire safety works, it would be a huge number gone from the list.
I just wondered why it has taken so long to actually offer these units to tenants?
If it says in the allocation process, does this mean that the unit is actually offered
out to someone or it still has to be offered so that someone on the housing list could
still receive an offer of Lorcan Court, St Lawrence's Park, St Lorcan or Mercy Way, Cherrywood,
Dublin.
And then obviously there's the other ones, fire damage and major works required when
they're handed back and I can understand those.
But really a number of years ago we were poor with our maintenance issues and it did improve
that the turnaround was much quicker.
But just looking at these, it's kind of slipping again.
And just really looking for explanations.
Thank you.
Thank you, Councillor.
Councillor Halpin.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:11:53
Thanks very much.
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:11:56
And I'm just putting this on the record
because I was talking to Ger Sullivan about it earlier.
I asked for this a year ago,
and I was informed that for GDPR,
we couldn't get this list.
And I'm just saying this here for the public record
because it should be noted that it could be possible,
maybe it's an accident, but it could be possible
that some counsellors are treated differently
from other counsellors.
And I'm putting that in the public records here.
It will be looked into and they will come back to me,
but it's pretty shocking because if this is under GDPR,
we should not have it here.
And if it's not, I should have had it a year ago.
So I'm just saying that because it's really, really annoying.
Just a couple of questions on it.
I agree with the Grange and in particular the one, yeah Lorcan Court I want to ask about,
they are in the allocations process. At the moment we seem to be offering well in advance
of them being ready, which I can understand the desire to do that because you want to
make sure you get all your ducks in a row and you try and get them. But the thing is
that we need to give realistic timelines to the people because a lot of people go, "oh my God, I'll pack up my stuff and move in with my mam" and try and
you know, save a few months rent for my new place and all of that and then they get stuck like the people who were
Up in Mercer who offered who were two years
After being offered before they were told and now I realise that that and I think that's the Mercer's way ones that they're still
not and
They're still on this list. I do I will after giving out the last one
I want to ask my is Rowan Hamilton house. So 20th of June 2025. It was whatever
that was ready and it still hasn't been allocated. I'm just wondering why that is taking us to
the problems with the units or what. And lastly, I do acknowledge there was a report from NOAC
which saying that I think Dun Laoghaire -Rathdown town is the second best in the country at turnaround
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:13:55
times. So, and that used to be the case, so fair play on that one. Thanks.
Thank you for your questions. Councillor Gildea, you're next.
Cllr Jim Gildea - 0:14:06
Where is Downville House, or Downville Court in Cherrywood?
I don't see it on the list.
There are some units that we have allocated before, we have taken them back, then we reallocated
them again, taken them back again.
I thought the second time they were allocated, at least, that all the problems had been solved.
That's it.
Thanks.
I will move.
Thank you, Councillor Gildea.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:14:37
Is there anybody else who wants to make comment at the stage?
I don't see any further hands.
Over to you, Karen.
Thank you.
Ms. Karen Cahill - 0:14:47
Just in relation to Councillor Smyth, first of all, housing transformation sits under
my remit as well.
So, it's through housing transformation that we generate these reports.
Maintenance is my area, the re-lets and the voids under maintenance, but I can tell you
in relation to...
Karen, I'll ask you to talk a bit more quietly.
Oh, sorry, am I too loud?
No, I'm not logged in.
Okay, sorry.
It's not the first time I've been told I'm too loud.
I'll whisper.
Okay.
Sorry.
I thought I would get away with that.
In relation to the Grange, that was an acquisition.
There were significant fire safety works that needed to be undertaken that weren't apparent
at the time of the acquisition.
I don't know the delay in getting to the stage where we have to get a contractor appointed,
but it was, I suppose, opening up works first to determine what needed to be done. A contractor
is on site there and as the units are being developed, or the fire safety works are carried
out, they are being let. So the Grange, I was checking with allocations before it came
up, they will be going on CBL. As they are released, we will be putting them up for advertising.
So they will be going on in the next week or two for the Grange.
Lorcan Court in St Lawrence's, there was a mass sign up last week or the week before,
so a lot of those units are now occupied or in the process of being occupied.
I am sorry, was it yourself, Councillor Smyth, that raised about the NOEC report?
It was Councillor Halpin.
Okay.
Again, look, the allocations process sometimes you have, you know, there's a couple of units
on this which would have had multiple refusals, for example.
Mercer, I'm not aware of the exact, and I should, yeah, again, in the allocations process is
is what I got from allocations as regards that.
So they would have been advertised and they are out for,
they are working through the expressions of interest at the moment.
And I see they are due to allocations to be handed over to us in November.
So they will be allocated as they become available.
Councillor Halpin, I am aware you had you were talking to Gerard today.
I know he has said to you all Councillors are treated the same.
I am not sure what happened before.
This is my view with this motion and this is what I have produced for the response.
Again as I said, in the NOAC report I think it was in the top five we were.
Our turnaround time on the maintenance end is between 12 and 13 weeks.
Obviously the allocations process can take, it is very hard to put a specific timeline
on it because you will have some people might refuse a property.
their circumstances may change, maybe in the course of the allocations process something
may come up on a Garda check, for example, so it is hard to put a timeline, but we do
turn them around as quickly as humanly possible.
There would be a few outliers on that where they would have significant works that would
have to be undertaken.
We would get back properties that would have extensions that had not been approved or attic
conversions or maybe the same family had lived there for decades and the house needs significant
works, rewiring all of that. But generally we are talking about between 12 and 13 weeks.
You will have some that will come in on the lower end, the apartments wouldn't take as
long for example so that does help on the overall turnaround time.
Again Domville, Councillor Gildea, you were asking about Domville again if it is on this
and it is in the allocations process that is, it is not on it, you were saying, sorry.
I have just sent a quick message to allocations because we have printed off anything that
is vacant from the vacancy on the housing system. So I will have to check that and come
back to you. Is that OK? As I said, maintenance is my area, I know about the maintenance ones,
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:19:15
but I said I will just take the allocations and the other ones when I am here. I will
double check and come back.
Thanks, Karen.
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:19:20
Just the one in Rowan Hamilton, why is that not yet allocated?
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:19:25
Ms. Karen Cahill - 0:19:27
Again the allocations process, I cannot say any more than that, Councillor Halpin.
They will be going through the process.
You may have people who, as I said, there could be delays with Garda checks.
It's very hard to put a specific timeline on the allocations process.
Councillor Smyth, your motion?
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:19:44
Cllr Carrie Smyth - 0:19:47
I would like to thank Karen for the report and the detail of the vacant units and why
they are vacant and responding.
Thank you.
I will note the report.
Thank you.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:19:57
OK.
Shall we move on then?
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:20:04
We have a proposal in second for that one.
So item six then is the update on Pierce Rovers Clubhouse.
This is for noting.

6. Update on Pearse Rovers Clubhouse

So I think, Jim Ryan are you taking this or?
Yeah, so I don't have a whole lot more to say on what's on the report other than we've
Mr James Ryan - 0:20:21
been working very closely with the club over the last few months.
We're getting very close to having, being able to give deadlines and everything else
on when we will have a finish line for this.
I've been speaking to Shane O 'Brien, who's the club appointed rep again today on it.
We're all in agreement on where we're going.
So yeah.
OK.
Councillor Halpin.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:20:41
Thanks, the club appointed reps are
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:20:44
Shana Brian, Richie and Podge,
not just Shane O' Brian, just for the public record.
Yeah, I have a few questions.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:20:53
So the second of October is in it
that is the deadline for receipt of pricing.
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:21:01
So can we have an update on, I mean, that was Friday.
So I mean, obviously you don't have it in for today,
but maybe you could circulate an update
or put this back on the agenda next month so that we know what the they were supposed to be in in
September so here we are into October so that's the appointed reps told me anyway um the so if we
could maybe have an update next month and just keep this on the agenda so it actually happens
it's brilliant that this is actually happening as everybody on this committee knows we've talked
about it for long enough so it is great and the other thing is about getting the list of the
80 ,000 donations that they have gotten, what is that actually going to be for and can they
have that in writing?
To release these funds, as we know and have said here before, if this is not sorted before
Christmas, those funds may well disappear.
We need that list.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:21:54
The reps need that list as soon as possible.
And also on the temporary and long -term electrics, which I don't understand the ins and outs
of, but can we make sure we are starting the works for the long -term when we open the temporary
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:22:11
so we are not into a huge delay?
There could be a lot of tripping of switches at the beginning.
It could take 8 to 10 months, as I understand it, but let's get it started as soon as we
have everything else in place.
So if we could get an update on all of those and next,
next month,
and if the appointed reps could have the list for the 80 ,000 would be worthwhile.
Thank you.
Councillor Lewis.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:22:39
Thanks, Cathaoirleach.
Look, thanks Jim for the updates and apologies.
I missed Councillor Halpin's first question.
If I, if I repeated it there, I got a bit distracted. Um, yeah,
Cllr Hugh Lewis - 0:22:53
first I'm just wondering is there a lease? There's no mention of a lease on this,
I am just wondering what the situation is in terms of that,
whether a lease is required and if so, what the situation is with
it. Obviously, this has taken forever and a day to reach. I
think everyone is relieved and will be relieved when they see
this on site. Certainly, for a lot of that time, not most of
that time, Jim, it wasn't yourself in this position. I think
everyone appreciates that.
My other question was who was going to pay for this exactly.
Thank you.
Councillor Kevlehan?
Just to ask Jim, has this gone out to tender?
Cllr Tom Kivlehan - 0:23:37
You know, looking at the report...
Read the final paragraph, Councillor Kivlehan.
Sorry?
Read the final paragraph.
The deadline for receipts and pricing.
All right.
Any other questions?
That has been finalised.
It was only finished by last Friday, so maybe we can give him a chance to have a look at them.
That is fine.
OK.
Councillor Moylan.
Go raimh maith agat Cathaoirleach and Jim, thanks for the report. Councillor Halpin, well done on the motion.
Cllr Justin Moylan - 0:24:05
I know we have all had motions on this, going back since I entered the chamber before me.
So it is good to see progress on this.
Jim, you might just give us an idea, indicative timeline.
Are we talking a year, six months, or can you determine that yet?
Thanks.
Have I got any other questions?
I don't really need questions unless they are really necessary.
I am watching the clock here.
Cllr Jim Gildea - 0:24:31
That's fine, Cathaoirleach.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:24:36
Just for clarification, they have done pricing on this, but has it gone out to tender to
Cllr Tom Kivlehan - 0:24:44
apoint to the person that would be supplying these. Is this under the tender situation?
But this is just the pricing has been done on a modular unit. But if it's over a certain
price it has to go out to tender. It's just to clarify that.
Thank you. Jim, do you want to come back in?
Mr James Ryan - 0:25:09
So, start at the beginning, the 200 ,000 that was previously discussed as being part of
the capital programme has been confirmed as available. So that is what I have to do
the project. We have specced out the changing rooms and toilet facilities that are needed
and we have gone out to get prices for those units from the companies available to us.
I think it was up to 12 companies can provide those modular build units.
So, um, last I heard we had a price back last week.
I haven't checked in today to know whether I've gotten a second one.
So I know I have a company who can deliver it for a price. Um,
then if that's the only one we have,
then we're in a position to go ahead and place an order. Um, so you're talking,
I think in eight to 10 week build process for the units to be built offsite.
And in that period, uh,
we would be able to go on site and prepare the ground works.
So that's where we are. So once we confirm the company we're going with and we issue
an order, then we know where the services are at the bottom of each thing and we have
to make sure when we bring them in and we place them on site, we have everything ready
to go, including the electrics.
So in relation to the 80K, so I know I have 200 ,000. I'm waiting to confirm what the price
of what is, what we're going to buy. Then I know what I have left to start doing the
ground works and then I eventually get to know how much of the necessary works are we
able to cover within our 200K and then we can talk to the lads about what else might
be needed. My own preference and hope is for us to try and do everything. It's for the
club but our facility is for us to provide and manage and maintain. So I'm hoping to
get to a point where we can do as much of the work as we possibly can with our budget.
And if the club has money, I would be happy for the club to use
it in other ways for themselves rather than on the facility,
would be my own preference.
But that is what the purpose of this week is, trying to
finalise how much different things are costing, including the
electrics.
I will very briefly, because I am briefly.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:27:15
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:27:17
I am sorry, Cathaoirleach. But the point of this money was it was a
donation for this, because I will just remind you, and you can
look back at the capital budget, it wasn't on the capital budget in March. This has been
a great boost and they've worked with you to do this. That money, it's not that they
owe, well they can buy a few extra pairs of runners if you don't need it. It is for this
project. It is a very, very generous donation and all of a sudden the Council deciding that
is how this project is coming along. They want this to be part of the project and that's
how the money will be released.
And the deadline for this is before Christmas.
This is the first I'm hearing of this,
and certainly when I talked to Shane and Richie and Podge
today, they suspected that was going to be the case.
And that's not what, they're really grateful.
These people who have given them the donation.
Just, I'd be wary of doing what you're suggesting there.
They want to make a contribution to this.
Can they have the list of what it is,
and can we make sure they get it before Christmas?
Because you don't just throw money back at people.
Thanks.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:28:23
Thank you, Mr Ryan. Maybe if there is an update in the meantime we might all get,
as an area committee, an update by email, that would be very useful. Thank you.
Okay, shall we move on then? Item 7 is ministerial, no correspondence, no business. I have five
motions to get to.

7. Ministerial/Departmental/Other Correspondence

Cllr Michael Clark - 0:28:48
Cathaoirleach, apologies. My last question wasn't answered, just in terms of whether a lease was required or not.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:28:49
You did ask. Do you want to answer quickly?
Mr James Ryan - 0:28:55
Sorry, Councillor Lewis. The intention would be a rolling licence in the same way as we

6. Update on Pearse Rovers Clubhouse

work with the other facilities rather than a lease.
Thanks.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:29:03
Thanks, Councillor Lewis. Sorry about that.

8. Councillor M. Clark

Councillor Clark, seconded.
Cllr Michael Clark - 0:29:08
Go raibh maith agat Cathaoirleach, thank you for seconding the motion. For the information of members,
this is about a tree in Barclay Court in Blackrock. I'm very heartened by the first sentence
of the report indicating that there will be crown lifting and minor crown reduction works.
And I just note in the second sentence it says it's scheduled to be undertaken as part
of the upcoming tree maintenance programme. So some sort of indicative timeline would
be of great comfort to the residents there. And I'd also ask, and I would ask the case
for all these tree maintenance issues if you could inform councillors after the works have
been completed. There is sometimes a mismatch between what residents expect and what the
Council delivers. I appreciate there are ecological reasons why there is that disparity there,
but it can often be the case that residents are disappointed by what the Council actually
does with those trees. So it would be of great comfort that you let me know and to let the
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:30:02
residents know that the work has been completed. But I would be interested in the timeline
as to when the works will be done.
Thank you.
I don't believe we have anybody from Parks at the meeting, unfortunately.
So I think Jim Ryan is going to give you an answer.
Mr James Ryan - 0:30:16
I'm not giving you an actual timeline, but just to say the lads are about to go out to
tender soon for the next batch of tree works and should be included in that.
But just to give a bit of context around trees, we are getting about 200 requests a week on
trees and trying to get them in, assess them, go and prioritise them, get them in a framework
work, it is not easy for us to give everybody the answers they want when they send in questions
around trees. About 40 % of our requests, CRMs, of 6 000/ 7 000 CRMs in a year relate to a
tree.
Thank you. That is fine.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:30:52
Cllr Michael Clark - 0:30:54
On the basis of the manager's response, I am very happy to accept the manager's support.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:30:59
Much appreciated. Moving on to Item 9 from Councillor Gildea, seconded by Councillor Burke.
Cllr Jacqueline Burke - 0:31:03
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:31:04
I hope Jim Ryan is in parks.

9. Councillor J. Gildea

Cllr Jim Gildea - 0:31:08
Because if he is not, I have been dealing with the wrong guy.
Just good to go.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:31:12
For the last couple of months.
This is not a motion asking that you do anything.
I just want to bring this out into the open.
Have it discussed because it has caused an awful lot of controversy.
Basically what has happened is there is coastal erosion along the cliffs at Corbawn.
Cllr Jim Gildea - 0:31:36
The report that came out on coastal protection suggested that certain things needed to be
done.
There wasn't anything, as I understand, in that report that said it needed to be done
in a hurry.
But I think as a result of some representations that were made by residents where they thought
that there was a point that was seriously dangerous that something would be done.
And in fairness to Parks, they got some money from somewhere and came up with a
plan. They also met resident representatives on site, agreed to
reduce the take from 23 metres to 10 metres I believe. And then at the other
end at the Cobawn end then they agreed to reduce it to 5
metres, which is a great step, which is a great thing.
Except what seems to be the main problem at the moment is
the type of fence you are planning on using. People want the
existing fence to be moved back. I have had discussions with
Jim and other people from infrastructure and climate change,
and they say the cost of doing this would be extraordinary. I would just like to hear what's been said.
My main reason for getting this out in the open, my understanding is that there isn't
a need for urgent works to be done on the entire cliff face. There is a piece where
the Council and the engineers or whoever that carried out the works realised that there
is a meeting of tides at a particular point and as a result of that there is extra erosion.
and it was that piece where the extra erosion is. It is only
about 20 metres long is what has caused that little bit to
become unstable.
I would ask the Parks Department, would it be possible to
just do that for now? Because, according to some experts, you
would have another 10 years before the entire cliff needs to be
done, in which case it would give people the view that they
have for now and would solve this problem overnight.
Thank you very much Chair, and sorry for going on.
That is OK.
Councillor Smyth, briefly.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:33:43
I would like to support that.
Cllr Carrie Smyth - 0:33:48
I actually raised this issue previously about the fence at one particular location along
the cliff on the green area at Corbawn Drive.
It is literally only inches away from going into the sea.
And someone who has walked Seafield green area on every second day.
It is amazing how quickly the cliff can erode with one rainfall or one really stormy.
I think in the interest of health and safety, the entire stretch of that green area needs
to be looked at and completed.
From my understanding, from talking to residents, there has been agreement now with what is
going to happen.
I would like to see the work starting.
Thank you.
Councillor Burke, briefly.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:34:37
Cllr Jacqueline Burke - 0:34:40
I seconded the motion because I have had a number of emails in from the residents of
Corbawn and I had a rep in and I got a similar response to this and they are not happy.
I think the big issue for them is their view.
I thought the wooden fence and hedging sounded lovely but they want the metal fence to be
reinstated and not the new wooden fence as proposed.
Thank you.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:35:03
All right. Go ahead, Mr. Ryan, please.
Mr James Ryan - 0:35:07
To be fair to the councillors who have spoken, they have all been making representations
on behalf of residents down there over the past few weeks. There has been quite a lot
of emails and things have actually moved a bit even since I gave this answer. So we have
a contractor due to come on site this week. They will remove the existing railing fence.
They will instal the timber fence similar to what's all along the coast and in other
places and there will be no hedging. So residents have come back saying thank you, that is what
we have asked for. If there is a further discussion on a different style of fence to be happening
in the future, that is fine. But for now from a parks point of view, we have been told to
put in a fence. There has been a lot of back and forth on it, but that is where we are
at the moment. It is the timber fence, similar to what we have done elsewhere.
Councillor Gildea, do you want to respond?
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:35:54
Cllr Jim Gildea - 0:35:56
Yeah, very quickly, just I want to respond to what Councillor Smyth said in particular,
because she must be talking to completely different residents than I'm talking to, because
none of them that have spoken to me are in any way happy with what was being proposed.
The update is interesting. I am surprised that you're going to remove the existing metal
fence along the entire length. That's absolutely new news, because what I was being told was
that the existing fence would remain in place
and the wooden fence would be put outside it.
I'm glad that there will be no hedging
because that would actually block things up.
Maybe you have to take this offline
because I'm happy to hear what you're saying.
When do you expect that contractor to start work?
Thanks.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:36:47
He was to start work this week,
Mr James Ryan - 0:36:49
Wednesday or Thursday of this week.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:36:54
Thanks so much. That's great. You accept the manager's report. Excellent.
Councillor Joseph, you're the next motion on my agenda. And a seconder?

10. Councillor T. Joseph

Cllr Thomas Joseph - 0:37:06
Councillor Smyth, thank you. Thanks, Cathaoirleach, and thanks for the report.
And I just want to ask, are we aware of the incidents or the complaints, the residents
from the Honey Park placed recently.
Did we take any personal safety audit in the last couple of months or after this many complaints
received from the community?
Has the public lighting section visited the place during the evening time or in the dark
time and don't know whether they are aware of any kind of incidents happening in this
area?
In this report it's mentioned the installation of lighting columns will have detrimental
impact on trees roots and the surrounding woodland environment.
So first of all it's surprising because we removed a couple of lampposts recently.
If you really want to put lighting we could have put there but we removed a couple of
lamplights in that area.
And when an engineering assessment being carried out about determining whether lighting could
be installed without having a significant impact on the tree roots.
Also, the alternative options such as solar powered or motion detection, something like
that can be installed or a low level lighting can be considered without having much impact
on the environment.
The report explains about the additional lighting is not recommended, but it does not demonstrate
that the specific safety concerns at the picnic area and the woodland pathway have been
assessed recently.
I fully appreciate for the biodiversity considerations and the need to protect bats and other wildlife.
However, the public safety and biodiversity should be balanced.
Modern lighting technology can often minimise the environmental impacts through shielding,
lower intensity lights and the timers, etc.
So while limiting the activity after the dark may be one objective, but darker, secluded
areas can also provide opportunities for antisocial
behaviour. In recent months we have experienced many
antisocial activities in that area and especially a couple of
times the play equipment were burned. I highly recommend to
consider some kind of lighting, low level lighting or motion
detectors to instal in the honey park to protect the safety of
the residents.
Thank you, Councillor Hall.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:39:31
Thank you, chair. I want to briefly support this motion. On the inner path of the park,
the lighting is very poor, especially during the winter months and perhaps motion detection
lighting would be very welcome along the pathway. We do want to encourage people through the
park to try and reduce the antisocial behaviour and lighting helps with that. Just to support
the motion. Thank you.
Thank you, Councillor Moylan.
Cllr Justin Moylan - 0:40:02
Go raibh maith agat Cathaoirleach, and well done, Councillor Joseph, on putting the motion. There seems
to be a difference of opinion or a difference of perspective from the Council to the Councillors
and the residents that we support and represent. When I read the reply, it reads as if a planning
issue. It reads as if we want to bring you a certain way through the park and light it
a certain way through our plan. You talk about biodiversity. This used to be a golf club.
There was plenty of biodiversity, but it seemed to be appropriate to give planning permission
for high -density housing. Now, at this point, where we talk about biodiversity, what Councillor
Joseph is referring to is deterring antisocial behaviour, which is well documented in the
estate, in the area, and has been plenty of representations about.
I would ask very much that this Council and the Executive in this Council would listen
to the perspective that has been expressed in that motion and
would react accordingly, because it is a safety issue, it is an
antisocial issue, and constantly the residents here keep
getting pushed back on it. They wanted that the park was
opened up, the lighting was removed, the CCTV was removed. All
of these things were brought to our attention at the taking
in charge stage. They have had none of them addressed
appropriately, and this would not be an unreasonable request.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Councillor Burke and then Councillor Fayne.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:41:21
Thanks for bringing this.
Cllr Jacqueline Burke - 0:41:26
As somebody who cycles through Honey Park to access Sefton and Rochestown Avenue, the
only cycle route through there is through the trees area because you can't cycle up
the steps.
So to either get onto the Rochestown Avenue or to get into Sallynoggin Park, you have
to go through quite dense tree area.
And that is a scary place to be cycling once it's dark,
particularly because of the antisocial behaviour.
So I would consider some kind of lighting that will be biodiversity
friendly for that. Thanks.
Councillor Fayne.
Councillor Fayne.
Thank you.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:42:08
I just want to agree with what's being said.
Cllr Mary Fayne - 0:42:11
I like, um, Councillor Burke,
I would go through Sefton, through the dark path that goes
to the right into Sallynoggin and straight down into Tesco.
As behaviour has been highlighted as getting far worse,
in recent times I just think yes it is very, very important to
improve the lighting.
Thank you.
Thank you.
A lot of issues raised there.
Mr Ryan, are you taking this?
Are you listening to our residents and our councillors?
Mr James Ryan - 0:42:40
Absolutely we are. Again, kind of like trees, lighting seems to be an issue that officials
and Councillors can't seem to find a common ground on. There are quite a few requests
along this line and when we go to the professionals they will say biodiversity, you can't install
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:43:04
lighting in these areas, you will have a negative effect on biodiversity. Then we have the whole
Mr James Ryan - 0:43:08
safety issue around, you know, does putting in a light actually make it safe? I don't know that it does.
I don't know what the right balance is.
Typically we don't light playgrounds, we don't light picnic areas because they are not intended
for after dark use, they are daytime use.
I don't know what answer or comfort I can give you here tonight.
There is a question occuring on the full Council agenda around lighting in this type of area.
I don't know whether it is at full Council that that kind of topic needs to be debated
and discussed further.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:43:44
Councillor Halpin, in fairfness, I am watching the clock and it wasn't your motion.
I didn't speak before because I agreed with what was being said.
That is very good.
Cllr Melisa Halpin - 0:43:50
But it is actually a fact that lighting makes it more safe.
It is in all the reports that come out of the gender -based violence groups.
It is a fact.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:44:02
And I think in fairness to Councillor Burke, I think I
wouldn't fancy cycling through a dark area. But if it is the
only method to get through that estate, because you can't go
up and down the steps, it does seem daft.
Councillor Joseph, back to you.
Thanks, Chair, and thanks, Councillors, for the support of
Cllr Thomas Joseph - 0:44:17
this motion. Many of you are actively involved in this area.
And management side, I haven't heard anything about the
protection of the people or safety and limiting the
antisocial behaviour or the opportunity for putting a motion
detecting lighting or something.
So I'm asking for to consider that option,
a motion detecting lighting or some other option,
that's because it's too dangerous.
And this is not like a, many times there is a
antisocial behaviour happened and attacking people.
And even last couple of weeks,
there are many times the play equipment were burned
and people attacked.
So I want Council to seriously involved in that.
And also if the trees shade causing issue,
it is better to prune some trees
so the better lighting will be there.
And it's not just for biodiversity.
Again, it's a highly density area
and a large number of people living there
and many of them are walking in the road
in the evening time, even six o 'clock, it's dark there.
So I'm asking for a report as mentioned in the motion
to come in the next Council meeting
with the options to put more lighting in that area.
Thank you, Councillor Joseph.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:45:29
I think in fairness, I think a lot of cross -party
have looked for more information there.
So I think maybe I might ask you to bring this report
that Councillor Joseph is asking to the next meeting.
And maybe some of these areas that need lighting
are really properly assessed, okay?
Are you happy to accept that as the?
I will go with my motion.
You want to put your motion?
Are we in support of the motion?
Great.
Mr James Ryan - 0:45:55
Thank you.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:45:56
I was just checking.
Mr James Ryan - 0:45:58
There is a motion on the full Council agenda.
It has been on it since February.
The chief executive reviewed the Council's policy towards the provision of lighting in
parks with a view to increasing public safety, mitigating antisocial behaviour and extending
effective use of green spaces within the county.
Unless that is actually met, discussed and sets out a policy, am I in a no man's land
like in terms of individual sites about what I can and can't do unless there is an agreed policy?
This is very specific to Honey Park.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:46:32
I think the residents of Honey Park had a certain regime under the developer of the
estate.
When the Council took it in charge, things changed and it appears to me not for the better.
It's not my area.
I don't have any skin in the game, but I think a lot of people here would like to see some
movement on what is being asked for here.
Can we move on then? Your motion number, I don't even know what number it is, 11. Go raibh maith agat, Cathaoirleach. I'll second it.

11. Councillor M. Clark

Cllr Michael Clark - 0:47:00
Thank you very much, Councillor Cathaoirleach. I am obviously less satisfied with the response
here and acknowledge that there is no one from the parks department to answer the particular
question at hand. Again, it speaks to the, I think we were told last time? Mr. Ryan, of course, will respond. He has many
facets to his job but he may not be at the co -face on this. I just wonder again
it just points to the disparity between what residents expect and what the
arborists will deliver and again perhaps it's a we need to change to our tree
policy as well as a need to change to our lighting policies to be discussed
with other other situations. I just I will ask when can I bring this up again
can those same residents bring this up again in another forum is there
some delay before I can ask again or do I have to wait for the next season? Go raibh maith agat.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:47:47
Anybody else want to come in on this?
Councillor Dockrell.
Thank you, chair,
for getting my name right eventually.
But in any events, I just want to agree with Councillor Clark, but I am also just amazed
we have to keep on asking these questions again and again, pruning of trees.
It is like, I feel like a broken record at this point.
Cllr Maurice Dockrell - 0:48:17
We should not have to be asking for this.
I feel sorry for the residents very much on this.
I am fully behind Councillor Clark and his desire to get this done.
As are you, our new Cathaoirleach.
Thank you.
Very good.
Mr Ryan, very briefly.
Mr James Ryan - 0:48:37
As I said, the number of CRMs we get in relation to trees is quite big and the questions are
growing.
thing. When you look at them, they are actually kind of
contradictory. Some people want us to top them, crown them,
take them out, put in different ones. The requests we get are
huge. There is a tree policy in place. So when requests come
in, they are assessed by someone who it is their job to make
an assessment of the tree. So some of the requests we get,
there might be someone's preference that it be topped, be
crowned. But when we send out someone whose job it is to
assess it and make a professional determination on what needs
to be done, that answer doesn't always align with what someone might like to be done. And
again, I don't know what the balance is there. How do we, like, do we just go, we forget
the tree policy and we forget the actual care of the tree and just do whatever people want
us to do when they ask it, but then we're not really caring for the trees, if that's
the case. And again, so I'm not the professional. I'm just someone speaking on behalf, giving
an opinion of what I've, from what I've seen in relation to CRMs, there's quite a lot,
They are not always consistent in the same areas.
Councillor Clark.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:49:41
I respect the manager's response.
It is actually intellectually coherent and I acknowledge that.
Cllr Michael Clark - 0:49:45
I would just perhaps ask in solidarity with the residents who asked the question, and that as a part of a procedural
motion that has no real effective power, I think we should still put the motion.
I would ask the members to read the motion.
at least.
Great.
Okay.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:50:02
Item 12 is more ministerial.
And that's okay.
They are only for noting there is nothing there anyway.

12. Ministerial/Departmental/Other Correspondence

Cllr Carrie Smyth - 0:50:12
Now, Councillor Smyth, we have to finish at 5 to 6.
So you are going to be very quick.
I am happy to accept the report.
I believe a briefing will be taking place.
So thank you.

13. Councillor C. Smyth

Very good.
Cllr Marie Baker - 0:50:20
And that's second by Dave O 'Keefe.
Sorry, I didn't notice you seconded.
Pardon me, Jim.
Sorry, I didn't hear.
We are not fighting with that.
Last of ministerial correspondence item 14 for noting.
No business there.
We have finished ahead of time.

Part 6 - Architects, Water Services & Miscellaneous Business

Sorry, hang on.
Karen, go ahead.
I have been waiting for an update in relation to Donville.
Ms. Karen Cahill - 0:50:55
I know there has been toing and froing on this, but at the moment that has not been
officially handed over to the Council yet, so it is not appearing as a void.
OK.
All right.
Thanks.
Thank you very much, everybody.
That concludes our meeting.
Blackrock Local Electoral Area
Fine Gael
Killiney-Shankill Local Electoral Area
Fine Gael
Blackrock Local Electoral Area
Fianna Fáil
Administrative Officer Community and Cultural Development Ballyogan Regional Temporary Rest Centre
Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council
Blackrock Local Electoral Area
Fine Gael
Dún Laoghaire Local Electoral Area
Fine Gael
Killiney-Shankill Local Electoral Area
Fine Gael
Dún Laoghaire Local Electoral Area
People Before Profit
Dún Laoghaire Local Electoral Area
Labour
Stillorgan Local Electoral Area
Fine Gael
Dún Laoghaire Local Electoral Area
Green Party
Killiney-Shankill Local Electoral Area
Independent
Dún Laoghaire Local Electoral Area
Fianna Fáil
Killiney-Shankill Local Electoral Area
People Before Profit
Senior Executive Officer
Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council
Killiney-Shankill Local Electoral Area
Labour Party